A Librarian’s Take On “13 Reasons Why”
It’s the show everyone’s talking about: Netflix’s “13 Reasons Why”. Everyone, including parents, preteens, and teens, are talking about it. I hear it at school (I work at a middle school). I hear it from my 20 something year old friends. I hear it from parents my age and older. And there’s some good reasons for it. The acting is superb. The story is raw and honest and real – not something you see a lot from Hollywood. The plot is catchy, and the kids look like real – admittedly prettied up versions but still real – regular kids. It has an anti-bullying message. It brings some rough topics up for discussion.[themify_quote]But there’s a difference between bringing up difficult topics and glamorizing them. There’s a difference between reading about them and actually watching them.[/themify_quote]
But I have some serious concerns.
Let me start out by saying I read the book and watched the entire series. I thought the book was great, much for the same reasons. I believe it SHOULD be part of the classic YA canon. It has a place at the table and is much needed by many young adults/teens. The writing is excellent. The topic is timely, but classic all at the same time: be kinder to people, you never know what they’re going through. It reads like real life, and it does have some disturbing moments… because a book about teen suicide SHOULD be disturbing. It’s not an easy topic and it should shake you to your core.
But there’s a difference between bringing up difficult topics and glamorizing them. There’s a difference between reading about them and actually watching them. And I think that’s where the show goes a little over the line. For those of you who are only 4 or 5 episodes… or even 7 or 8 in, you’re going to be all “Calm down morality police. It’s not that bad.” Okay, so I’m not even talking about the moral issues. But they’re there too. Parents should know it depicts teens drinking, using drugs, getting into fights, being bullied, bullying others, having sex, using profanity… basically doing all the sketchy things teens are known to sometimes do. All in all, very similar to something you’d see on whatever the kids (AGH! I sound SO OLD) are watching on the CW nowadays.
– Spoilers Ahead –
However, here’s the issues: It also shows two graphic rape scenes. A student who has engaged in self-harm. At least two scenes of students getting the you-know-what beat out of them without defending themselves. And yes…the ending, a very graphic depiction of Hannah’s suicide. The camera doesn’t move away for a second from the wrist slitting in the bathtub.
Which, by the way, is different from the book. In the book she overdoses on pills. But the show creators decided the wrist slitting had a bigger visual impact. And it does… but maybe not the kind of impact they planned on.
Here’s a List of My Concerns
Trigger warnings, like whoa. The show does give a heads up before the episode plays that there will be mature content and what the quality of that content will be. But still…even if you haven’t experienced that kind of trauma, it’s still super intense.
This show is straight up dangerous for those with inclinations towards suicide ideation, self harm, or even just serious mental illness. It’s like throwing a match at gasoline soaked kindling and hoping it doesn’t start a fire.
Suicide was the 2nd cause of death among teenagers last year. We DO need to be talking about it. We need to be talking about the causes, and how to prevent it. We need to be talking about what to do if you have a friend who you suspect is suicidal and the signs to watch for. We need to be talking about mental illness (which contributes to over 90% of suicides) and viable alternatives to suicide. THE SHOW DOES NONE OF THESE THINGS. Hannah does list her causes- 13 reasons why, and the people who hurt her, etc. but the show doesn’t touch on things like depression, anxiety, or post-traumatic stress. It touches briefly on her sexual assault but doesn’t give any help on how to process or find resources to heal from it. Outside of her internal monologue, it shows a few vague signs that she was considering suicide. But not much that could really be helpful to teens trying to prevent it in their social circles or themselves. And it definitely didn’t show a positive way to reach out to adults who could help: if anything the message was “adults will let you down…every time. Don’t even bother”. It talks about suicide, but doesn’t show any viable alternatives.
Hannah is treated like a martyr. You see the show from the point of view of a teenage boy who was in love with her, so obvs the portrayal is going to be a little skewed. He is wracked with guilt as he goes over the various trials Hannah has gone through and he sees very little imperfection in her actions or behavior. But we know people aren’t perfect. The characters mention once or twice that Hannah was full of “drama” but we don’t see that. Kids need to know that people who are considering suicide aren’t saints…and in fact they might be the kids that are always full of drama or that drive you crazy. Or they may just be invisible. Hannah talks about feeling invisible, yet she walks into a party of “popular kids” and they all start chanting “Hannah! Hannah! Hannah!” Hannah is not invisible. She is not portrayed as annoying or overdramatic. But the kid full of suicidal thoughts in their math class might be. Mental illness manifests in a variety of ways in adolescence, and some of those ways aren’t so pleasant. We don’t just need to save the sweet lonely Hannah Bakers of the world… we need to save anyone we can.
It glorifies suicide. Instead of showing the awful reality of suicide, which is supposedly what the creators were trying to do, Hannah is almost hero-like for her actions. She’s one of the main protagonists and you’re rooting for her to triumph over all the obstacles she’s facing. And this what makes the show so dangerous. The book does a better job of balancing out Hannah’s issues with reality. The show doesn’t. It’s basically sending the message: “Look how the school put up memorials for her. Look how nicely everyone talked about her. Look at how all the people who picked on her felt bad and their lives were ruined… wouldn’t that be perfect revenge? And look, even her parents were kind of okay in the end once they realized that she had her reasons.” And for teens who don’t have that fully developed prefrontal cortex, who are pretty much full-speed-ahead-nevermind-the-consequences, that is very, very dangerous.
- A Parent’s Guide to Teen Depression
- Tips for Watching New Netflix Series 13 Reasons Why
- Teen Suicide Prevention in Huntsville
You don’t pick up most of this until the last three or so episodes. And by that point it’s too late, you’re hooked and you’ve got to see how it ends. I know. I went into the series having been warned of this, and I still fell for it hook, line, and sinker. And it’s going to win awards. No doubt about that. Which will draw more and more people to watch it.
The Consequences of 13 Reasons Why
I am very concerned that this show, instead of saving lives like it’s creators intended, may have some very tragic consequences instead. I’ve never struggled with suicidal ideation, just regular garden variety depression and anxiety, but it was a pretty heavy blow even to me. And I’m a grown up, with a fully functional understanding of actions and consequences. I am also self-aware enough to realize “Hey, this is triggering some not-so-good thoughts” and have 10+ years of therapeutic coping mechanisms in place to deal with that. Your regular depressed 14 year old kid? Not a chance. And that is a serious, serious problem.
There are no happy endings here, no real redemptive message. Yeah, it’s quality TV, but is that worth it? Parents, if you want to watch it to see what your kids might be going through, that’s one thing. But be very, very careful about letting your kids watch it. Watch it with them please and open up the discussion.
Again, the book could be useful, but the show… I’m just so concerned. #ReadTheBook
You Might Also Like…
Lexie Robinson Austin is one of the few born and raised Huntsville natives. She is a stepmom to one, a librarian to many, a reader of books, and baker of cookies. She likes ridiculously impractical shoes and the color pink.
My friends and I were talking about this yesterday. I am chronically depressed, so I’m pretty sensitive to its portrayal in film and literature. I think you are spot on in this article. Quality TV, but irresponsible to an extent.
I wish I knew all these details beforehand. My 17 year old just finished watching it and now I feel like I need to watch it (or print this out) so we can have a very necessary discussion.
I’m watching now. I def think you should watch it and discuss it with them.
Isha, there is a link above that might be helpful. Look for “Tips for Watching 13 Reasons Why” for some good discussion points that you can use to open up some dialogue. It’s a good way to check in and see how your child is feeling about the show!
These are valid points and they absolutely needed to be brought up. I’m sure there are those out there who didn’t realize the serious nature of the show. I started watching and had no idea what I was in for. However, I believe these views express some unreasonable expectations and deflect personal responsibility.
A TV show brought a major issue to the fore. They did a darn good job making it uncomfortable and as real as anyone can expect TV to be. They depicted one plausible scenario. Of course there are countless more. Of course suicidal tendencies come in many different forms with varying signs.
This is a show about teen suicide. That’s a very serious topic and watching it IS a very different experience than reading it or hearing about it. Frankly, I think it should be a no-brainer that parents should watch it first to see if it’s going to be appropriate for their kids. If they decide to let the kids watch it, there should ABSOLUTELY be some parental participation. Why wouldn’t a parent watch this particular show with their kids? Is it that hard to invite open dialogue after each episode? How could you not see the benefit of listening to your kid’s honest reaction to this? How can you not take the 5 minutes to Google extra resources for teen suicide help?
Netflix isn’t raising your children. You are. They did their part, now it’s up to all of us to do ours.
Jennifer, I totally agree that parents should be involved in this!!! I fear that not enough parents know about the show’s content. So many kids are watching this (in what sounds to me like unsupervised settings) and it’s possible that parents think this is just another series based off of a YA novel. I hope this post makes them more aware of what exactly it contains and they can start the dialogue you mention above.
Thank you so much for the article and bringing some common sense to this discussion. As a mother of two and grandmother of one, it very much concerns me that shows like this can just lay it all out there and walk away…parents are left to pick up the pieces! I’m so glad I don’t have to raise my children today. My children grew up in a world where you rarely heard of suicide at all but almost never among the young. In 2014, the annual suicide rate Increased 24 over the previous 15 years. That’s what what we should be talking about! Why? WE all have a responsibility to our children, parents, grandparents and Hollywood!! Sometimes they listen to Hollywood more than us. We can’t be with them all the time and control everything they do, not in this technology age. But my children grew up in a lot more positive images and feedback on tv, in the movies and all around them than we see today. I think it requires more responsibility than ever on all our parts to search deep to find where this is coming from and also not to glorify the negative and harmful just to cloak it in “reality “. While we are looking, let’s love in each other! LOve on your children and give them FaceTime. Love on their friends too! Love changes things!